patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Poll: Will You Shop at Save-A-Lot?

New supermarket a subject of consuming interest.

  • Will you be shopping at Save-A-Lot?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes
        104 (44%)
    • No
        94 (39%)
    • Not sure yet
        38 (16%)
    Total votes: 236
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
 

The news that a Save-A-Lot store is moving into the spot vacated by Superfresh has triggered responses ranging from disappointment to outrage. Based on comments at Arbutus Patch, many in the community are not pleased that Arbutus didn't land a Trader Joe's or a Whole Foods.

When push comes to shove, will you shop there? Take our poll and tell us.

Alicia Knecht

5:07 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

Although it would be nice to have a Trader Joe's or a Whole Foods in the area, the fact is, this area could not support that kind of store. Arbutus is a very blue collar, struggling middle class kind of neighborhood, and those stores sell higher priced foods. I for one wouldn't have shopped there. This area needs a regular grocery store.
I really miss Superfresh and how convenient it was, and I look forward to having a similar store in the area. I just hope it can survive after Superfresh failed at that location.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bridgett Rusen

8:11 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

With all due respect, you are completely wrong. First of all, just because a shop is located in Arbutus does not mean ONLY Arbutus residents would shop there. Not that I think for a moment Arbutus residents could not afford/would not appreciate and enjoy/do not "rate" a Trader Joe's-type grocery, but even assuming you might be correct on that point, what about affluent Catonsville and Relay just down the street? Don't Arbutus's middle class, upper middle class and flat-out wealthy neighbors factor in?

I am working class, live paycheck to paycheck, earn an hourly wage, etc., etc. and I drive to Columbia on a regular basis to shop at Trader Joe's, MOM's Organic Market, Harris Teeter, and cannot wait for Wegman's to open. I travel to Hunt Valley to shop at their Wegman's and to Towson for Fresh Market -- not convenient, but totally worth it. I may not do all of my day-to-day shopping at these stores, but I look forward to shopping there whenever I can. From talking to other moms at my childrens' school and social events, I know for a fact that many many other women take their grocery dollars to Columbia as well.

Too bad for Arbutus, a nice shop would have raised the bar and attracted a lot of revenue and drawn customers to other shops in town, might even have encouraged existing store fronts to spruce up to stay competitive. Instead, a store like Save A Lot only adds more mediocre unappealing junk to the pile.

Comment_arrow

squeapler

9:53 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

While Arbutus does have its share of "blue collar, struggling" people, there are also quite a few people who don't fit in that category - for example, white collar workers who take the train to city jobs and like living in a nice community with yards and older homes, and people affiliated with UMBC. You've probably made the same silly generalization many people do based on price of homes and so forth. Actually, the fact that it's not a super-pricey area gives me MORE money to spend on things like decent food.

Also, even blue-collar people have some concern for what they and their families eat. Eating healthy is on everybody's radar screen these days, and a lot of people are concerned about what they eat and don't just want to inhale a bunch of lousy canned or sugar-heavy food because it's cheap. Much less serve it to their kids. You feed kids a bunch of sugary cereal and you're peeling them off the walls all night.

Bridgett also makes a good point that a decent store would draw people from outside the area to shop here. The only problem I see with that is the current Superfresh location is not the most accessible place in the world for traffic coming off major thoroughfares, and as other people have noted, the building itself might not be big enough to do a good job of accommodating a Trader Joe's.

Shirley Roemer Walton

5:41 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

Arbutus Superfresh did not fail as a store,it failed as a company,I know because I worked there,lots of shoppers loved that store.I think Save-A-Lot would do very well there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Killi Macklin

11:38 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

Sorry, Shirley, but every time I ever went into Superfresh (maybe once a month?) it was dead. The aisles were too narrow to get more than one cart through at a time. The produce was hit or miss. The lighting was dark.

There aren't enough people in Arbutus to support Mars, Giant and a third full grocery store... especially since Walmart opened. I talk to my father and he does all of his non-perishable food shopping at Walmart because their everyday prices are in fact cheaper than sales at Mars.

Alicia Knecht

5:49 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

You're right Shirley, it wasn't that location. I was in there nearly every other day and the place was usually busy. I was really sad to see it close.

Reply

CAW21227

7:19 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

Sav A Lot is not a "regular" grocery store. If you go to their website you'll see that most of their goods are their brand not nationally recognized brands. You'll also see that they are located in ratty neighborhoods. We don't need a Trader Joe's or a Whole Foods, you are right, this neighborhood couldn't support them, but we do need something better than Sav A Lot. I don't shop the store in Brooklyn Park and I won't shop at this store. There is something about the store that turns me off.

Reply

Chuck

8:41 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

It all boils down to demographics and size of the building. Will we shop there ? Probably just running in for canned goods here and there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

9:56 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

as i drive out of my way to not shop at the walmart i will make sure i go out of my way not to shop at this other ghetto store. not even for a stick of gum. starting to hate this area more and more. ive always said if i wanted to live in the ghetto i would have moved in the ghetto. i was tricked into thinking arbutus was a mayberry town. its more like ghettoberry.

Krista

9:52 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

I am another Arbutian who shops at Trader Joes, Whole foods, and Safeway. Just because we live in a middle class neighborhood doesnt mean I want to 2nd rate groceries. Price isnt everything....what about quality?!?!?! Looks like with Sav a lot filling the Superfresh vacany I will continue to travel to Columbia and Ellicott City to shop.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Killi Macklin

11:36 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

You are in the distinct minority. I also regularly ride up to Rte-175 to buy groceries at Trader Joe's for specialty items. And for general goods, I go to Mars. There isn't a need for 3 major grocery stores within 3 miles of each other.

squeapler

10:04 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

I'm not sure whether I will shop there till I see it. I tend to shop the "outer aisles" of supermarkets for things like meat, produce, milk, eggs, and the occasional Lean Cuisine or Smart Ones frozen dinner. I'm certainly not interested in buying carts full of canned or packaged foods, especially not if it's "store brand". So if I go in this store and it has a reasonable selection of meat, produce, etc. then I will probably shop there to save on gas. If it does not have a good selection of fresh foods, and/or looks trashy, I will keep burning my gas to drive over to Giant Foods just like we have been doing.

And I agree the store management is what ruined Superfresh. Giant is not exactly in a wonderful location economically either, yet its store is much, much nicer. Superfresh didn't carry a lot of the brands I liked to buy (They never had "Spaghettios" for example, only Chef Boyardee which I do not like) so I pretty much used it for "outer aisle" shopping too.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

10:29 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

you were making sense until you said "ghettios". once i read that the only thing i got from your post was a basket of lean cuisine and spaghettios. you cant do both if you are looking to eat right. either you are or you arent. just sayn.

Killi Macklin

11:43 pm on Friday, November 4, 2011

That property is best served as something other than a grocery store. It would require retrofitting the building for another purpose, but grocery isn't it.

Arbutus as a whole has a major issue with local business. East Drive is a no-man's land other than Sorrentos and Ritas. I have no reason to ever go into the old Superfresh lot for any of those businesses.

Unfortunately, Arbutus doesn't support its own. They just opened up a coffee shop and a sandwich shop, but I assure you more people would rather go to Subway to Dunkin Donuts.

Then there is the empty brick piece of prime real estate in the middle of town from the Sulphur Spring Inn. Would love to see a nice restaurant in there, but who knows how long it will sit vacant.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bruce Goldfarb

12:57 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

Allow me to take off my Patch hat and speak as a resident. East Drive is hardly a no-man's land. I don't know if you've looked around downtown Arbutus recently, but there's a lot going on. We have good Tex-Mex, a kebob place, a hookah bar, Larry's 1332, Heister's Grille, Ben's Beans, Art and Cake. Many of these are new. There is a lot going on in Arbutus now.

Comment_arrow

Nikki Marlatt-Young

1:03 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

I would have to disagree w/ your statement regarding East Drive "is a no-mans land other then Sorrentos and Rita's". Please don't take this the wrong way, but what happen to Leon's, Paul's, Hollywood, Hair Studio, Shell Station, Lucky's Curves, Domino's Pizza,, Mikes Pizza, Rite Aid, Sherman Williams, Center Court, Subway, Papa Johns, Dollar General, Center Court! Please don't make the area sound like all we have is a little coffee shop & sandwich shop. I don't feel Arbutus has a major business issue.... Maybe a few shops located on East Drive could use a make over but I don't think we should consider it a no mans land by no means is this a ghost town!

In reference to the Sulphur Spring Inn.... Its only been vacant now for what 2 months! Not all business shut down due to lack of customer business. Please know the facts before making it sound like the Arbutus Community has abandoned their own!! ;)

Comment_arrow

Nikki Marlatt-Young

1:05 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

Thanks Bruce... Goes to show you "Great Minds Think Alike"!!!! ;)

Comment_arrow

Sean Tully

9:43 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

East Drive may not be a no-man's land, but not long after the Sun goes down, it sure looks and feels like a ghost town.

Comment_arrow

Sean Tully

9:47 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

Let me think of all the places I go to do business in Arbutus:

1) Hair cut at John's
2) I am always in Rite Aid (East Drive)
3) Mike's Pizza
4) Sorrento's
5) Subway
6) Mars
7) Rite Aid (Maiden Choice)
8) Rita's
9) Arbutus Library
Probably more if I think about it.

Comment_arrow

Sean Tully

9:51 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

Whoops! I forgot:

9) 7-11 on Francis Ave (99% of the time, I drive to that one instead of the one in Violetville. I hate the one in Violetville. It's so...greasy feeling.
10) The Chinese restaurant in the same shopping center as the 7-11 on Francis Ave.

Comment_arrow

Chelsea Willis

10:46 am on Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Sean, I have to agree with Bruce on this one. There are a lot of good businesses in arbutus and Ben's Beans specifically does NOT close its doors at sundown. On Every Friday evening, they have live music and this week it will be saturday too. Perhaps you should stop on in.

Comment_arrow

Chelsea Willis

11:14 am on Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Killi, I disagree with your statement that "Arbutus doesn't support its own" I believe a more correct statement is "its own, doesn't support Arbutus". Which is exactly what you pointed out that people want to go to Dunkin Donuts instead of Bens Beans and quite frankly, Bens coffee tastes better than Dunkin Donuts and less expensive.

If the residents don't support local people and their businesses than all we are left with is places like Sav-A-lot. In addition, Our Saviour Lutheran Church in Lansdowne has been a pick up spot for One Straw Farm CSA all summer. Perhaps those looking for fresh, organic vegetables at reasonable price should inquire about picking up next season which starts in May.

Comment_arrow

Karen Carothers

3:28 pm on Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Forget the Save-a-lot. Turn that into a parking lot for downtown Arbutus. I never shop at any of the stores on East Drive because there's never anywhere convenient to park! I gotta compete for street parking at home, I don't want to mess with it when I shop, too.

Sean Tully

9:38 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

I used Super Fresh basically as a larger version of 7-11. Once they stopped carrying the type of cat food that my lions enjoy, I only went in for bread and milk. I doubt I will ever set foot in Save-A-Lot.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

12:36 pm on Saturday, November 5, 2011

i hear that. will not ever support a store whos exclusive soda is called bubba.

Shelly

10:48 am on Saturday, November 5, 2011

As a family of 6 with 4 boys and a husband I welcome Save-A-Lot with open arms. My boys are ages 3-17 and Save-a-lot offers fresh fruits and veggies at a lower cost along with other great items! We ALWAYS have friends over that we are feeding as well. As a large family in this area, I would never be able to shop at an "upscale" store. I am not "GHETTO" or "uneducated" or any of these stereotypes that many of you are putting on this store or the people who will or will not shop there. I shop at Dollar General all of the time and see MANY of the people who live around me in there. Dollar General saves my family a ton of money every week. The people who work there are nice and I can always get everything I am looking for. It is really sad and unfortunate that Arbutus has so many closed minded people. I think it is a great town, we always visit the local businesses. We love taking walks to the ICC, Eskimo Shack, we see all of our movies at the Hollywood. I am a mom, a volunteer for our school, a coach, and a friend and I will be shopping at Save a lot every week....but you call me whatever you would like for that.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

12:25 pm on Saturday, November 5, 2011

sounds like you overestimate your positive qualities there. good for you for being so arrogant. when you said we love taking walks to the icc. first thinking was why you walking to the inercounty connector the it hit me ice cream cottage. guess my overestimated way of thinking got the better of me regarding how educated you are. althought it wasnt hard to figure out as you talk of fresh fruits and veggies yet you then you talk of only ice cream and dollar store purchases. sorry i think most around here have a higher standared for living. please leave the city in the city.

Shelly

12:57 pm on Saturday, November 5, 2011

You are very rude and I have to wonder how much you do to better this community. If taking my kids for treats once in awhile or saving money on my paper products, cleaning supplies and toothpaste makes me trasy so be it. Again, I love this community. Sorry, you do not enjoy it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

2:46 pm on Saturday, November 5, 2011

as you contiune promoting trash maybe you should stop wondering so much about what i do for this community and start worrying more about what you are doing to this community. like many others i would like to see the increase in the community value. not campaign decrease. i was not aware caring about the value of my home and the community appeal was being rude. look at the other locations of those stores and compare house values in those locations. im sick of people like you who support the low life ghetto trash appearance. you must not be worried of your house value either. i mean its only one of the most important investment we make. but since you wonder what i do to better the community i will tell you like i tell everyone on here that writes silly things such as you. i put the lid on my trash can.

Bclass

5:45 pm on Saturday, November 5, 2011

FYI-The Columbia Wegmans will be opening June 17, 2012, and it appears that Whole Foods will be opening on the Columbia lakefront as well, according to the Tales of Two Cities blog.

Reply

Susanna

11:47 am on Sunday, November 6, 2011

Oh my. I'm a little late on this, but am very sad to see this news. I grew up in Erie PA in the 80's and 90's where we did much of our shopping at the West Erie Plaza. This included a movie theater, department store, two Hallmark stores, a drugstore, jewelry store, Murphys, library, fabric store, bookstore, and assorted restaurants and clothing stores. After Murphys closed and local department stores became a thing of the past, two new anchor tenants moved in: Gabriel Brothers (a lower end Value City), and Save A Lot. Today, most of that plaza sits empty. The only store left that I used to frequent is the Chinese restaurant my friends and I used to go when we had a half day in high school. It's so filthy and run down, I'd never set foot in it now. Save A Lot is the kind of store that brings down property values, and brings the type of people to our community that won't support the nice businesses we already have, but make them want to leave for greener pastures. This is not a good sign for Arbutus. I know we don't have the median income or traffic flow for a TJ's, but tearing down the building and putting in a park would have been better for the community than this.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

2:10 pm on Sunday, November 6, 2011

its sad but the only people that will understand this concept of the store bringing down the community and area value is those that have invested our hard earned income. losing 20-50 thousand dollars in property value is not on an renters mind nor do they care. its sad that the rest of us have to put up with their ignorant ways.
if my house value hadnt taken such a hit in the last couple years i would have been gone a long time ago. but i cant unless i take a loss or rent it out to someone in which then i would gamble getting a poor renter who will distroy my property which will cause more hardship. in 2 years this area will be nothing more then city life.

Susanna

11:54 am on Sunday, November 6, 2011

Oh, and in answer to the question. No, I will never, ever shop at Save A Lot. I care about the food I put in my body and the effect of food production on our economy and our environment. I currently make regular trips to Columbia and Pikesville for Trader Joes, and a monthly visit to the Annapolis Whole Foods. When I need a key ingredient quickly I might go to Giant, but only as a last resort. I have a garden and support our farmer's markets. You may find buying cheap food the easiest option in the short term, but you'll pay for it later in poor health and a weak food economy.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

8:41 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Stephanie - Check out Mom's (My Organic Market) in Jessup, too. Fabulous place. And all their produce is non-GMO.

Chuck

12:26 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

The projected opening is by the end of Feburary 2012, The Hagerstown Almanac (also unscientific) is predicting a heavy snow on March 8-10....Perhaps the true test will be to see who shops there and who does not, come the first significant snowstorm.... I'm betting milk, bread, & toilet paper will take precedence over foie gras , free range chicken, and tofu....It will be interesting, and rather funny...if someone were to be on Hypocrite Patrol......and to bust a naysayer.......ha ha.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

2:21 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

IF it takes a snow storm to get some people to spend $20 at the new Save-A-Lot, that's not a good 'forecast' for the economic success of the store. Now, if we lived in Alaska...?

Mike McAuliffe

12:48 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

I too am disappointed that a store of low quality is all that could be attracted to this location, but there isn't a whole lot that anybody can do about it. I see a lot of complaints about it posted on this page, and some off them are coming from readers that proclaim to be bettering their neighborhood simply by bagging their trash. Though not bagging your trash would severely further degrade their neighborhood, if simply bagging their trash is the lone action they take in trying to solve the issues degrading their neighborhood of Arbutus and devaluing their property, good luck on bringing up that value. This alone doesn't cut it. Even some people in the hard ghettos bag their trash, and it hasn't turned their neighborhood around. What does get degradation reversed, or at least stymied or slowed down, is real action. Local community organizations like Arbutus Improvement Assoc., Halethorpe Improvement Assoc., and Arbutus Bus.& Prof. Assoc., among others, try their best to create this real action, and often succeed. Online news, like The Patch, offer these great opportunities to speak candidly, but sadly, like most freedoms and privileges it is abused and used irresponsibly by fools. Online anonymity allows foolish people to say foolish things with no repercussions, and too much credence is given to there hollow gripes. Rants are never addressed with real and sustained action, but legitimate grievances through community meetings can be.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike McAuliffe

12:50 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

Ranting on about Ghettoberry isn't going to get Floyd, Barney, Andy, or even Otis to come back to Arbutus.

Comment_arrow

Joe Knecht

1:40 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

Just to validate a well thought-out post, here's to you, Mike. Thanks for posting!

Comment_arrow

al walker

10:32 am on Monday, November 7, 2011

its because they packed up and moved to relay with thoughts now of renting out their houses and just moving to ellicott city.

Steve Goodnow

5:50 pm on Monday, November 7, 2011

We need an "occupy Arbutus" to stop the save-a-lot

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

9:10 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

A possible motto: "Save a lot: Stop Save-A-Lot." ;-p

al walker

6:03 pm on Monday, November 7, 2011

let us know when your ready. just need a day or two to slip my vacation request in. i have about 2months of leave. but after that id be there by satellite.

Reply

CAW21227

7:47 pm on Monday, November 7, 2011

Perhaps if Sav A Lot knew about the 38 comments on this article and the 84 comments on the other article about the store, maybe they would think twice.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike McAuliffe

9:29 pm on Monday, November 7, 2011

I'm sure the Save-A -Lot executives are quite knowledgeable in demographic research. After even a less than delving research they would see that many of the negative comments were just reiterations a few peoples adamant displeasure, and that many of these same folks post complaints on many other issues. They'll take their chances on their already gathered research. Yeah it's a bummer that this is the best store that we are able to attract. Maybe it's a sign of the neighborhood's future. Who knows. Why didn't the recent arrival of some small promising shops cause even a fraction of positive comments that this store got in negative ones?

Lorna D. Rudnikas

7:02 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Rather than a parking lot---how about a well controlled recreation center for young folks....too late now, but much needed nonetheless to take the place of teen centers that disappeared over the years, sadly!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

8:49 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

What a great idea, Lorna. This location/space would have been great for a rec center. It's a shame that, instead, "the county" decided to tear down trees within a 14-acre forest and build a rec center next to the library and senior center.

Nikki Marlatt-Young

9:31 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Susan, I agree with you for the most part about the rec center. Although our area really did need the beautiful library & senior center. The facilities for the most part are utilized for very many things. I do however agree that a recreation center is needed for more then just sports activities & zumba! I would like to see a teen center!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

9:35 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

I advocated for (and continue to advocate for) rehabbing existing spaces rather than building in a forest and taking down trees.

Comment_arrow

Lorna D. Rudnikas

1:51 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Mentioning the words "teen center" today seems to be accepted as a negative....and that is unfortunate. Arbutus Teen Center was renowned in the 50s and 60s as THE PLACE TO BE ON FRIDAY AND SATURDAY. Rules were in place, everyone felt it was their social scene to protect and therefore rules were followed. Anyone stepping beyond the boundaries set was banned and that was a huge social no,no. It could work today with the right mind set and I think teens need that social seen, great music, place to talk, laugh, dance and enjoy among their peers. A whole lot better than walking the malls. Yike!! Does require some chaperoning.. but during the 50s, 60s teen center scene the chaperones were hardly noticed at all. Teens helped to make the rules and peer pressure controlled the scene nicely.

Comment_arrow

Susan Mazzoni

2:15 pm on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Sounds wonderful, Lorna! Do you know who sponsored the Teen Center? And was it only open on Friday & Saturday nights?

Rosebud

11:29 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

Arbutus has a number of new businesses that are worth a visit. Look around your own neighborhood. I don't agree that a Save-a-lot is the way to go with the departure of Super Fresh. I shop at Mars more frequently than any other grocery store, but I also travel to Columia to shop at Trader Joe's. I was hoping for a Trader Joe's in Arbutus or something similar. It would help to bring our surrounding neighbors into Arbutus. I feel we have lost a valuable opportunity.

Reply
Comment_arrow

al walker

11:59 am on Thursday, January 12, 2012

couldn't have said it better myself.

Leave a comment